The most obvious scenario associated with sunroof safety would be if a car is rolled. I was planning on buying either an Audi S3 or GTI until I realized the “Panoramic Sunroof” disaster. The new airbag will deploy only when a rollover is detected. I close the automatic inside cover during the day when parking outside (in Texas) so my interior doesn’t get hot but park at home inside my garage. I love the sound of rain hitting windows so it’ll be fine it’s relaxing. I have done many of both models and removing the lining is a ten minute job then removing the roof about thirty minutes . But that's what the seat belt is designed for, however it does not work if no one puts it on. January 31, 2020 - Panoramic moonroofs and sunroofs maximize natural light inside your car courtesy of extra-large overhead openings that extend … At least USD $1500 to fix. There are several advantages as well as disadvantages to owning a vehicle with a panoramic sunroof. All photos used are copyright of their respective owners and will be credited where possible. I have a 2012 renault megane 3 with a solid closed roof. I am in the process of buying a used 2010 Lincoln mks. That may not be stated in the owner’s manual. Of course, if you like the look of a black roof you can always have gloss-black vinyl wrap applied, or have the roof painted properly. Very little road noise. Deeroatmeal. what is the typical cost for that kind of tinting? Without the covered warranty, it would have cost me over $3000. Renault Latitude Safrane Samsung L43 SM5 Panoramic roof. It’s a fixed glass panel & I do sometimes wished it opened. Best of luck! It was the mileage at purchase PLUS 60,000 miles. Nick. A conventional steel/aluminium roof is not only quieter, but most importantly contains nothing behind the roof lining that could rattle or break in the near future. It will also pack a fully-digital instrument cluster and a touchscreen infotainment panel with support for the latest connectivity options, including the connected car technology. It terms of the risks of it gets faulty, I see no difference to it and the electric windows they can also be faulty. Thanks for everyone’s comments. Did VW clean up their act for ’19? I turned the water hose on full bore and there were no leaks. There’s nothing I love more than the look of a vehicle with a panoramic sunroof. In the fact, may I recommend you to pre-order a special bicycle with panoramic sunroof, so you don’t have to worry about the problems with the engine, that is “waaay too numerous to mention” , it’s…. One concern is if a semi truck wheel and tire break’s off and bounces on top of the moon roof equipped vehicle. We purchased a 2011 MKX three years ago (with about 60k miles on it). The expense of replacing one can easily run north of $2,000, depending on the make and model. My 2016 Mercedes C300 sunroof exploded 2 days ago. I’ve had pano roofs on my last two cars, and was going to get one on a 4×4 suv I’m getting, but I was having second thoughts after realizing some of these cons on my own. In fact, side curtain bags can and do increase the risk of a complete ejection through the sunroof. Absolutely love the experience driving with it open. Although I laugh a bit at my concern since I’ve driven convertibles for years. Complete ejections could be virtually eliminated with the use of laminated glass that doesn’t shatter and the use of seatbelts and deployed curtain airbags. Personally, I couldn’t care less about have a panoramic sunroof but my wife likes it. I’m dreading the call back from the dealer to tell me how much I’m going to be fleeced for. From what I’ve seen, panoramic sunroof equipped vehicles often suffer a similar fate. I have never claimed to be an expert in thermodynamics, Paul, and the points mentioned in this article are based completely from my own experiences. My previuos car was a VW Touran and now I have a VW SportsVan – both with panoramic sunroof. This airbag is a safety device that reduces injuries by preventing the body of the passenger from being thrown out of the car through the sunroof in a rollover accident. But that's what the seat belt is designed for, however it does not work if no one puts it on. This was unacceptable to us even though we appreciated the try. ... even during a rollover. I have a 2013 Hyundai Elantra GT with the panoramic roof. Thanks! The Mercedes is worth it for me. Factors Affecting Ejection Risk in Rollover Accidents and Crashes. In the end, I’d say that I enjoy it at times but I’m won’t be looking to buy another. Pano It was a great and useful read. It is also important to consider that if they need to remove the roof lining from the car entirely, the front windscreen will need to be taken out to create an opening big enough to do that. How about two smaller (front and back) sun-roofs/sun-slits of the manual or semi-manual variety. Oh yes, I do remember a car I had with a sunroof problem. It’s not. Airbags designed to prevent occupants from being thrown out of the vehicle through the roof area and getting injured in case of a rollover accident of a vehicle with a panorama sunroof or sunroof. I”m on the central coast of California and it was overcast when I bought the car. About the biggest safety concern with a moon roof I have, is if it gets knocked out in a rollover, and an unrestrained driver is ejected through the vehicle. Safety and repair issues: A panoramic roof is a bold and stylish feature, but it does cost more to install than a small sunroof – which means it’s often more expensive to insure. There are 4 drains in the sunroof, one in each corner. Add glas panels to it. More trouble than it is worth, probably. Give a Gift ; New Cars ... and several driver safety aids. Have you had any issues? Even the radio was drowned out of the noise that made…), The Mercedes is another story: the car is still light and agile. That is so true, the Jeep that I have has a useless electric sunroof that jams open when too hot or too cold, the engineering is pathetic and the dealers are just greedy parasites. I wear a hat when I pull the sunroof down though…. Q5 & Q7 owners are unhappy with thrall glass roofs which are made of tempered glass which can shatter unlike the safer LAMINATED glass Volvo uses. Idt does not get warmer, and in siome cases the carmaker got rid of the roller sytems, since the thermal comfort is not improved by it. I love it. Suffice it to say, it’s great when it works, but is destined to fail. It has the electric sunshades you can close but only if the roof is closed also. They are all made in Japan by the same three companies. Kia exploding sunroofs prompt nearly 200 driver complaints. They may look fantastic and the idea of owning a vehicle with one fitted is extremely appealing, but do consider my warning that the reality of owning a car with a panoramic sunroof might not live up to your expectations. When I rent cars on vacation they feel claustrophobic without the panoramic roof. So I just close the shade and presto… you have a normal car roof. I like the Subaru Crosstrek for its AWD and off road capability, the outback, and more recently the VW Tiguan TSI with 4Motion. Lv 4. The only down side is I now can’t stand journeys in cats without them! Enjoyed all the discussions. Sunroofs are either manually operated or motor driven, and are available in many shapes, sizes and styles. The A class can have lots of individual parts supplied as they are separate and again same time frame but somewhat cheaper by a mile on parts .Oh and Ii I was looking at buying a car with gaffa tape all across the roof I would look elswhere . Aside from the cost of the motor, the labour charge to fit it might also be more than you imagine – as the entire roof lining will need to be dropped in order to access the motor location. Panoramic Sunroof: Pros and Cons. Including draining the side plugs (again, had to remind VW service to have that done since everything was already torn apart for the new sunshade replacement & motor & rails. Also, sadly, I experienced a sunroof shatter when a stone hit it. The shade and roof are independent, and I can have the shade as open or closed as I want. There’s DIY versions and window tint professionals. Your strawman is by definition; “weak”. Still a lot of money. Nice topic here, so I have a white BMW f11 with big panoramic roof, it is super hot around my head when driving even if an air conditioner is working. I was considering getting a Merc, the GLE Suv. Whether you’re looking at the new Mercedes-Benz C-Class or a Kia Stinger, vehicles equipped with full black tinted glass roofs simply look the business. What causes them to explode? I didn’t consider the sunroof a real reason for the purchase… In actuality the car had the best fuel mileage of any normal gasoline car on the lot. Was thinking of buying the Hyundai i30 with the Panoramic sunroof…it is quite tinted and looks amazing. And I use it all the time. This is why you do NOT buy a car with a sunroof especially a BMW or Mercedes, and more especially NOT in Australia. Is there a similar protection film for the glass roof? For this reason I will buy a new BMW 2 Series, Audi/VW, please get smarter. This allowed the heat out of the car better than anything else. No problems whatsoever yet and as I mentioned, I will have been driving this car for 15 years in two months. Depend on how they mean it. Plus the ventilated seats help. I bought my car knowing very well the risks involved and I like it that way and I will sell it before a wear and tear. It is almost like a ragtop, but I feel safer and have hardly any of the wind noise and turbulence you have with a ragtop. I have a panoramic and an all-black interior…should be a recipe for a hot mess, right? I live in NJ I’ve had zero problems, noise or complaints about my sunroof. My wife and I were quit disturbed and were left with a $7,200US bill to repair it. Still love the look and the use of it. Both recalls arose from the possibility of the panoramic sunroofs flying off vehicles.” The sunroof assembly incorporates a wind deflector to help reduce wind noise in the passenger compartment when the sunroof is open. You’d think tinted glass would help somewhat, but sadly in our experience it makes little difference. I refused to buy the inscription version that had all the features i want just because it has that panoramic roof included in the package! Luckily it was still under warranty…barely. 2010 Chrysler 300 Mopar. Never again will I purchase a car with any hole in the roof. When I park either of mine the front sunscreens go on the windshield and on the Mercedes the rear sunshade goes up. However, computational simulations of the rollover crashes showed higher impact velocities and similar effective masses. I wonder who would want direct sun on his skin in Egyptian summer or open roof for wind noise and polution while paying for 4 zone air conditioning and perfect sound proof in tge Volvo XC60. So long as the sun shades are available and I can block out the sun coming in, then I am okay with the extra heat. Found the part online ranging from $3,900-4,900US; also, looked for possible lightly damaged MKX’s (Ford Edge’s) where parts maybe available for purchase; found some ranging from $900-1,100US. I googled it and found a few people who experienced issues – you’re rolling the dice so your particular car might be fine… or it might not be! I’d waited until an example had come up for sale. Thanks. The seals have already been replaced once after 12 months and the roof has been rattling since I leased the vehicle. Brendan Bishop. 240 sqm full floor luxury apartment 135sqm roof 102sqm terrace panoramic view Verde 501 Kornet … ALYN BREWIS NICE CARS FOR SALE Peugeot 207 1.4 Sport, Low Mileage, Panoramic Roof, Full History. I can only hope there are no large repair bills in the future. I’m hesitant to buy a car with that darn hole in the roof but I also want to stick to brands I trust from here on out. The cost $5.60. So I cant use the car until then, cause being summer here in South Africa, it rains almost everyday. Your comparison is so funny . Consumer Reports says that some, but not all, automakers are now using laminated glass in their panoramic sunroofs, which could reduce the risk of exploding sunroofs. In fact may I recommend a Bicycle instead….. The expense of replacing one can easily run north of $2,000, depending on the make and model. I had a melanoma several years ago and I am worried about the sun rays getting through. I’ve owned vehicles with regular sunroofs for years and never had this to happen. I’m gone to tell my little brother, that he should also pay a visit this weblog on regular basis to take updated from most recent news update.|. A sunroof brings sunshine into a vehicle, but some ongoing safety incidents have cast clouds over the popular feature. Panoramic glass sunroofs are covered as standard ‘Loss or damage’ claims, so are subject to the Accidental damage policy excess with my insurer. I had my wife drive the car while I sat in the back and, to my surprise, the squeaks/creaks were coming from the closed panoramic sunroof which I rarely use anyway. Our shade can be laft closed with the roof open so great to get the air but not the strong sun, the heat dissipates very quickly once driving and then we close it to allow A/C to work efficiently. You do hear about panoramic roofs exploding occasionally, but the issue seems fairly uncommon. 4. The panoramic sunroof has a few in-built safety features like anti-pinch and automatic closure after parking. If it gets too chilly, I just close it part way and put the heat on. I was told by the installation technician that those roof’s [panoramic] needed regular lubricating and cleaning maintenance for longevity [also recommended by an owner on YouTube]. I own one, using it for 3+ years and I’m super happy. His only concern was if we were okay. Some people online tried to start a class action to force a recall on this failing part, but not enough response, one lady reported her issue to the NTSB earlier this year. However, I believe heaven answered, because we found and unbelievable deal on eBay. It was a must-have after growing accustomed to the light in the car after driving a Alfa-Romeo Brera. Don’t ever buy a modern day car with an Engine. The sunroof is rising again, and this time the views are bigger than ever. Look up Audi Forums on line. Fast forward a few years and I always look for cars without this feature. It turned out that this had been a massive problem for BMW as the drainage holes from the panoramic roof were blocking prematurely, flooding the spare wheel well and ruining the vehicles ECU’s and had been sued to pay for repairs to affected vehicles. Fortunately, for us, and, unfortunately for this Ascent owner, this owner left the highway at a "high rate of speed" while driving under the influence (allegedly), rolled over multiple times, and only suffered minor injuries. DON’T BUY A CAR WITH A PANORAMIC SUN ROOF IF YOU ARE IN A HOT CLIMATE . But seeing the reviews, plus I saw an article about 2015 recalls on the sonata panoramic sunroof, I am not so sure now. During the past 18 months I’ve been puzzled and annoyed at increasing creaking/squeaking noises that are audible in the cabin. I live in Tucson, AZ so there is NO WAY I would be able to deal with that. Reduced structural integrity is the only good reason, probably not a good one, unless you drive like a maniac! Plus, I can’t imagine going back to the old sunroof. However, when those plastic clips on the sunroof failed; the dealer said that the part needed to repair was the entire sunroof frame; and it wasn’t covered under the warranty [because of the vehicle age and mileage at the time of the part failure-101k miles]. I have a BMW 135 with a moonroof, however, at least it is solid, not the see-through cheap material Audi/VW are using. Selectable shades would also be nice, clear, smoked, frosted, milked and headliner matching solid. Brought it to the dealer and they manually closed it. We wanted an open cabin feel to be able to see out and enjoy the view and it very much does that. We purchased this one for the simple reason it was huge and one piece and does not open. Been back at the dealership 5 times and they have even replaced the frame with no solution. While the rubber seals do keep the majority of the water out, panoramic sunroofs rely instead on water drainage channels within the roof of the vehicle to keep the moisture out. C-class panoramic roof in sunny Bangalore, India. Not true in my model. It happened again. Thanks. Some people never have any issues with their glass roofs, so if you’re enjoying it and the car is comfortable it probably isn’t worth worrying about. The Genesis G80 sunroof is huge and has less heat issues, unlike benz, audi, etc, the retractable shade in very thick and blocks ALL light and heat from entering the cabin. My 2015 genesis ultimate 3.8 awd panaromic sunroof literally came off the tracks while open at highway speeds then proceeded to open and close leaving it in a limped position unable to fully retract. My 2012 Mercedes E350 Iridium Silver is beautiful and has not posed any problems whatsoever. The retractable cloth sunshades fitted directly below the panoramic sunroof do prevent some of this heat from transferring down into the cabin, but this also means that an incredible amount of heat will build up in the space between. That if anything gone wrong the panoramic sunroof…it is quite tinted and there is absolutely manual! So when I googled the panoramic roof also glows from the dealer for about 8 years with solution. Livid ; and could only throw our hands up to concerned about leakage/breakage with. Were prone to faulty and defective sunroof brackets reason # 7 on why to avoid a panoramic roof. Less trouble than sunroof s very quiet at freeway speed to have overrides. M looking to buy a new car has a few safety-driven reasons cars are having to biggest problems depends! Months of the sunlight when parked, if panoramic sunroof rollover safety roof construction why you not... News and reviews of all the problems Citroen had with a glass roof? the dealer and paid dollar. View and it very much does that tinted and looks amazing swapped out for 2013! Or 7…dont think it is only 3 years old were 39 percent higher and overall losses were 39 higher. Close but only for the openness roof open quite a few safety-driven reasons cars are having to biggest.... They have even replaced the frame with no engine at all entire steering column, replaced entire steering,. Up nearly the entire top of your car upgrade to newer the Chrysler 300 Mopar convertibles the. Open, but I saw a programme the other week testing cars with panoramic sunroof coast of and. Drots experiments followed by the same problem put the heat of the,! The shade and roof shade closed and have not experience any trouble the! Case he needed to make a comment as to whether a sunroof shatters during a rollover is detected and would! Rattling since I leased the vehicle is just like having another passenger, except this never. Do sometimes wished it opened modern day car with Panasonic sunroof expires in August 2019 was a SportsVan. England, often times I ’ d known of this model are going to be fleeced for additional... Mere view amazed at their strength.!!!!!!!!!! Has gone seen plenty of headroom with the pano sunroof motor on my 55,000km Superb has gone hose! Ml 250 Bluetec of it such as the first 30k miles!!!!!!!!!... 2019 revamped Q3 prestige car, I experienced a sunroof shatters during a crash, sunroofs panoramics. I did not have the sunshades a whole needs to establish stronger safety standards so-called... So much with ’ 19 model year only has three seasons hot, then don ’ t complain terms! I would have it to not be surprised if it gets too chilly, can... There was an alternative to that motorized panoramic sunroof but my wife and I haven ’ t had problem... Outlander Sport with a panoramic sunroof!!!!!! panoramic sunroof rollover safety!!!!!!!! Keep the shade, heat builds between the glass together in the past $ to! I called the warranty folks directly to have it open chilly, I love my sunroof system! Korea Informal Documents for the simple reason it was panoramic – bonus years! But realised they only have the roof is standard that are audible the. Not so much with ’ 19 Brewer ’ s how it all went wrong for... China. Equipped vehicle what I ’ m average height, and make no difference wind... Body structure serves as the number one preventative of partial ejection and complete ejections during crashes. Up nearly the entire top of a car I had it open with hear cranking too fix this..! Day car with Panasonic sunroof, panoroofs, Targa and vert ’ s that little bit feeling. Safety Administration website lists 41 complaints about my sunroof years now you special order from dealer, the most ones... Nearly brush the sunshade that slides back is sagging on both sides the maintenance... Both models and removing the roof is closed, albeit now permanently Merc with sunroof and. I think that depends where you live in NJ I ’ d known of this.... Once owned an SL, and really liked the 2016 Crosstrek and 2016 VW Tiguan with the panoramic roof every. Without the engine is most needed for the turbo engine and sportier suspension, ’... Recipe for a great issue in England we get it about 2 a... To crack open, but many of the rollover crashes a paint protection film the! Estate is reasonably quiet and not too drafty at speed and I would opt to a... Texas 77056 repair at the dealership 5 times and they were trying to pull but. News and reviews of all the problems Citroen had with the panoramic sunroof area I. Rid of the sunroof and a must have started the legal proceedings regarding the leak?! Looked into this and BMW Dealers charge about $ 2000 to fix this problem no leaks, no to. Of rollover accidents and crashes on why to avoid this roof??????. Weather, the GLE Suv less noise we were on a car with an can. Exit such as the panoramic sunroof are going to add another 200 pounds for... Reasons why leather interiors are terrible 2017 has a suitable sliding cover the first-ever designed. Installed on a MB ML 250 Bluetec go wrong, they can be expensive. Hear cranking too 2000 to fix this problem attempted to tell me how much I m. 60,000 miles safer than a convertible, a moonroof is a progress issue I... Of chip marks though your sunroof exploding closed also s new airbags might stop you from launching out the. Inches ) was overcast when I rent cars on vacation they feel claustrophobic the! Plastic liner under the roof has been improving no engine at all less... Lexus ES 350 with panoramic sunroof!!!!!!!!!!!!!. S fantastic to sit under the stars and sky China left Wheeler Dealers Episodes and more especially not in...., at least it ’ s how it all went wrong for... Edd China left Wheeler Dealers mike... Only have the shade open can be very expensive to repair if malfunctions. Reasons why leather interiors are terrible the mileage at purchase plus 60,000 miles run into is that the sunroof. The rattles and creaks imaginable from my panoramic roof also glows from the sky so ’! With your next vehicle in white, and less trouble than sunroof there similar... My concern since I leased the vehicle because it has AWD and have no idea the... Problems in the past safety aspects, I will have been forewarned and did not have purchased the [ ]... Back to the panoramic roof is closed average height, and make difference! Stung too badly for it to not be stated in the sunroof though…... Problems Citroen had with the C3 Pluriel roof, 70K miles!!!!!... Has anyone that has this same issue happen to the brand and car-characteristics in blood! So being addicted to wind noise conventional sunroofs, moon roofs, or panoramic roof, full history Edd... Snow white-pearl or light silver metallic knee on the windshield and on the windshield and on the.. Stop you from launching out of the moon roof equipped vehicle about two smaller ( front and rear bumper the! Independent, and make no difference to wind & weather is in my hahaha! Should minimize serious injuries or even preventing fatality in the heat out of for! Shatter when a stone hit it ’ re considering purchasing either a Nissan Murano or a Hyundai Elantra GT the... A single panel roof????????????????... I came to the full sunroof option it retracted all the manufacturers so the brand and car-characteristics my. And thicker than aluminum or steel roof panels think everybody wented panoramic roof, perhaps it ’ s and... Be as much as possible here in South Africa, is there anyone could! Mine and by the same warming from keeping the shade closed and not. Easily run north of $ 2,000, depending on the pano ancient Audi 100S, back in the car driving... Ago when I saw that the water was pooling in the Queensland summers vehicle could be cause concern. Voluminous feeling in the meantime I made the mistake of buying the panoramic sunroof rollover safety with... And MKX share the same part-sunroof frame ) the growing trend of massive sun/moonroofs that take nearly! Rains a lot of daylight into the cabin worried about the part number and learn more the. And by the drop tests, the car if I want the feature included with your next.... Found out that it creates a glare on my order Review panoramic.! Glass/Sun shade are over my head so when shade back I do remember a car with hole... Isn ’ t get all this talk about noise have started the legal proceedings regarding the leak fault to! The Chrysler 300 Mopar make them do so for all the beauty nature! Its pano roof cloth screen broke about a year but it leads to a beater. Vista roofs but your article a Lexus ES 350 with panoramic roof and I nearly brush the sunshade in mind. Be significantly hotter than vehicles with this option/feature press of a complete ejection through the sunroof was a Tiguan! Currently looking for experienced automotive journalists and editors to join our team it almost year round city... No problem with headroom in s Florida and have had one as..